Spelthorne's auditor found significant weaknesses in its finances and governance in 2025/26, even as debt fell from £1bn to £718m. It made five key recommendations.

Spelthorne Borough Council’s external auditor has found significant weaknesses in how it runs its finances and its governance, as it did for 2024/25. The auditor also says the council’s “direction of travel was positive” in 2025/26.

The findings are in Grant Thornton’s interim auditor’s annual report for 2025/26. It goes to the council’s Audit Committee on Thursday 26 November.

The headline findings

The auditor rates the council against three tests of value for money, on a red, amber and green scale. Its summary ratings:

Area 2024/25 2025/26
Financial sustainability Red Red
Governance Red Red
Economy, efficiency and effectiveness Red Amber

Red means significant weaknesses were found and key recommendations made. The third area improved to amber, but the auditor kept its key recommendation there on procurement and contract management.

It makes five key recommendations for 2025/26 and one for 2026/27. That compares with eleven key recommendations for 2024/25.

The good news in the report

  • Debt fell from £1 billion to £718 million during 2025/26, the report says. Repaying loans early earned the council a discount of £34.3 million.
  • The council brought in a new policy for setting aside money to repay debt, which the auditor calls compliant. It raised that annual charge by £46.6 million.
  • The auditor credits the council’s “mature approach” in not asking the government for exceptional financial support, which would have meant more borrowing.
  • It closed its earlier recommendation on the council’s performance measures.

What the auditor wants fixed

Selling property and paying down debt. The council plans to sell nine investment properties worth a combined £400 million by the end of March 2027. The auditor says this “must proceed at pace”. The council’s own response says only two commercial assets would then be left for West Surrey Council: the Porter Building in Slough and the Charter Building in Uxbridge.

Its housing company. Knowle Green Estates Ltd, the council-owned company, lost £2.7 million after tax in 2025/26, and its losses are growing every year. A decision on its future was due this autumn but has not been made. The auditor says losses will pass to West Surrey Council if it is delayed. It also says the council must “urgently” review how the company is overseen. One councillor is now the only member of its board.

Working with the commissioners. Government-appointed commissioners have run Spelthorne’s commercial decisions since 8 May 2025. The report records that councillors twice voted to delay a property sale this year, on 6 August and 22 October. Each time, the commissioners used their powers the next day to order the sale to go ahead. We reported the first of those orders in August.

Risk and procurement. The council should update its strategic risk register. Its head of procurement post has been empty since 2025/26, with cover from another borough council.

The money pressure this year

The report sets out the scale of what the council is carrying in 2026/27:

  • £53 million to set aside for repaying debt, against £13 million a year under the old policy
  • £32 million in debt financing costs
  • a forecast overspend of £5 million at the end of September, mostly because property sales have been slower than planned

If the sales do not happen, the council forecasts its usable reserves will fall to £14.2 million by the end of 2028/29, the auditor says.

What “disclaimed” means here

The auditor says it will issue a disclaimed opinion on the council’s 2025/26 accounts. That means it will not give an opinion on them. It gives the reason as the national backstop rules for clearing a backlog of council audits, which affected the figures carried over from earlier years.

The auditor made no statutory recommendations and issued no public interest report.

What it means for you

  • Spelthorne is abolished on 1 April 2027. Its debts, property and housing company pass to West Surrey Council, so these decisions shape the new council’s finances for every Spelthorne household.
  • The Audit Committee meets at 7pm on Thursday 26 November at the council offices in Knowle Green. The agenda and papers are online.